Indy’s ‘Mrs. Doubtfire’: A standout lead, a forgettable score

November 18, 2026

“M

“Mrs. Doubtfire”- Courtesy of Joan Marcus. Used with permission.

rs. Doubtfire,” the stage musical based on the 1993 film, was a lively family comedy carried by an exceptional lead performance, though a predictable story and forgettable score kept it from inspiring. I saw it Tuesday at Clowes Memorial Hall in Indianapolis, part of the Broadway in Indianapolis season; the tour plays through Nov. 22. Craig Allen Smith led as Daniel Hillard and Mrs. Doubtfire in his tour debut, with Melissa Campbell as Miranda, Brian Kalinowski as Frank and DeVon Wycovia Buchanan as Andre.

:Mrs. Doubtfire: – Courtesy of Jon Mrcus. Used with permission.

The premise stayed the same. Daniel, a charming but unreliable actor, lost most of his time with his children, so he became Euphegenia Doubtfire, a warm but strict Scottish nanny. The musical kept the film’s best-known comic set pieces, updated the jokes and gave more attention to how the divorce affected Miranda and the children.

Beneath the comedy, the story was about family, fatherhood and identity: a family, it argued, is whatever its members make it. Daniel learned to be a present, responsible parent, not just a fun one.

Smith met the challenge of the lead role masterfully, though through craft rather than reinvention. Following Robin Williams is no easy feat, and that performance can’t be recreated. His Daniel was a charming, flustered actor, and his Mrs. Doubtfire was warm and strict. The quick changes were crisp and funny, and his comic timing was sharp: the physical comedy was fearless but controlled, and the dialogue came fast and clean. The opening scene was a crowd-pleaser: as Daniel, a voice actor in a studio, Smith raced through a rapid montage of characters, and every voice landed.

The supporting company was lively, and the three children gave the family scenes real feeling. The score blended pop, disco and ballads. The emotional peaks were “I Want to Be There,” Daniel’s plea to stay in their lives, and “Let Go,” Miranda’s ballad. The rest were set pieces: “Make Me a Woman,” the disco makeover that created Mrs. Doubtfire; “Easy Peasy,” the kitchen scene; “He Lied to Me,” a flamenco showpiece; and “What the Hell,” the children’s rock-edged outlet.

The leads’ vocals were exceptional. Smith sang “I Want to Be There” as a real plea, the nanny’s patter falling away, his voice clear and steady even after racing through quick changes. Campbell gave “Let Go” a rich, controlled sound that built from restraint to full-voiced release. Alanis Sophia, as Lydia, the oldest sibling, stood out with a strong, clear voice and stage presence beyond the role’s demands. The choreography was well executed, but several production numbers, including the tap number, the flamenco showpiece and the disco makeover, felt inserted to give a lackluster score extra energy rather than growing out of the story. They were fun to watch, but they were spectacle added on top of the songs.

Broadway reviews had plenty to say about the design, and the tour kept the same designers under director Steve Edlund. David Korins’s set drew the most praise, called detailed, nimble and almost lavish. Philip S. Rosenberg’s lighting was flashy and solid, though one critic found it over-bright. Catherine Zuber’s costumes were campy, eye-catching and built for lightning-fast changes, though one critic thought they didn’t quite fit together.

“Mrs. Doubtfire”- Courtesy of Joan Marcus. Used with permission

The cross-dressing drew mixed reactions when the show opened on Broadway. Some critics praised the musical for acknowledging, more than the film did, that Daniel’s disguise was queer-coded, and noted the joyful, camp tone of the makeover number. Others said it still relied on familiar “man in a dress” jokes, and one listed it among Broadway musicals that missed chances on gender and sexuality. Reviewers who praised the show’s warmth mostly treated the disguise as a means to an end rather than a statement about gender.

Little felt fresh, and that included Smith, whose performance was only an impression. The story was predictable and the score was the bigger disappointment: several numbers worked in the moment, but few stayed with me. It was a competent, well-staged tour, best suited to families and fans of the film who want a faithful, feel-good evening rather than something new.

“Mrs. Doubtfire” continues through Nov. 22 at Clowes Memorial Hall, 4602 Sunset Ave., with performances at 7 p.m. Wednesday through Friday, 2 and 7:30 p.m. Saturday, and 1 and 6:30 p.m. Sunday. Tickets are available at BroadwayInIndianapolis.com; the show was nearly sold out in early November. It runs about 2 1/2 hours and is recommended for ages 8 and older.

photo: Josh Humble

About Tom

Tom Alvarez is an Emmy Award-winning documentary filmmaker, journalist, and arts administrator with an extensive career spanning media and the fine arts. His diverse background as a producer, director, actor, and lyricist provides him with unique insight and access to review the arts across Indianapolis, Central Indiana, and beyond.

For over 50 years, Alvarez has documented theatre, dance, music, and visual arts. His work has been featured in the Indianapolis Star, NUVO, Indianapolis Monthly, and Dance Magazine, among others. A former contributor to WFYI-TV’s Across Indiana, he now hosts a regular performing arts segment on WISH-TV’s Life. Style. Live!. He is also the host and producer of the podcast On the Aisle with Tom Alvarez, part of the All Indiana Podcast Network presented by Circle City Broadcasting.

As a principal of Klein & Alvarez Productions, LLC, he co-created “Calder, The Musical” and serves as the managing director of Magic Thread Cabaret. Additionally, he is an active actor and model represented by the Helen Wells Agency and Heyman Talent Artists Agency.

You can follow his work on social media @tomalvarezartswriter and @tomalvarez1.

On the Aisle Team

  • Creation, content, and publishing: Tom Alvarez
  • Public Relations: MEG & Associates
  • Web development: Site Potion

Leave a comment

* required field